After midterm blowout, ‘America First’ can rise
By Ethan McIntire · Contributing Writer

Republicans didn’t lose the midterms. They forfeited them.
For years, the Republican establishment, neoconservative warmongers and an army of spineless Trump apologists preached “America First” while preparing to sell out the people who put them in power. The blue wave unfolding now is not a mystery, and it is not the voters’ fault. It is the bill coming due for a party that abandoned its own base the moment power felt secure.
Donald Trump ran on a clear platform: no new wars, mass deportations and affordability. He has gone back on those promises. He went to war with Iran. He backed away from the mass deportations he sold as non-negotiable. Trump also failed Americans where it mattered most: affordability.
Trump’s policies have made things less affordable, while allowing Israel and pro-Israel donors to pull America back into another Middle Eastern conflict.
The Department of Government Efficiency was sold as a revolution against waste and entrenched power. In practice, it was a colossal failure that helped open the door for companies like Palantir, a data analytics and surveillance firm whose tools let governments integrate enormous amounts of personal information on their own citizens, deeper into the state.
Voters who wanted less government intrusion got more surveillance infrastructure. That swap should alarm anyone who claims to care about liberty.
On immigration, the flip has been just as stark. Trump went from promising mass deportations to arguing that undocumented immigrants in certain industries are too valuable to remove. The same movement that once insisted the border was a crisis now treats parts of the illegal workforce as too useful to touch. You cannot run on enforcement, then rebrand to allowing “essential workers” to stay as soon as donors and industries complain and still call yourself “America First.”
The same pattern shows up elsewhere. Aggressive AI deregulation brushed past public concern about removing safeguards. The Epstein files, initially dismissed as a “Democratic hoax,” were then drip-released in heavily redacted form. Victims deserve accountability. The public deserves to know why so much remains hidden and why this administration has resisted full transparency. Political games are not justice.
None of this had to happen. The blue wave was avoidable if Trump had remained the “America First” candidate he claimed to be. Instead, he caved to billionaires, wealthy donors and political action committees, including figures like Miriam Adelson, who poured $100 million into his campaign.
When a movement trades its voters for its checkwriters, it should not act shocked when those voters stay home or walk away.
I didn’t vote. That was not apathy, and it was not confusion about the stakes. It was a refusal to accept the broken promises from a party that asked for my trust and spent it on wars, donors and half-measures. When someone runs on “America First” and governs like the opposite, sitting out is not a betrayal of the country; it is one of the last honest responses left to people who were already betrayed.
Mainline Republicans told plenty of us that anything short of full loyalty was helping the left advance its agenda. That argument only works if the side demanding loyalty still stands for what it sold to the base. The GOP didn’t. So, I’m glad the Republican Party is facing the consequences of its own failures.
That might sound harsh, but it isn’t. It isn’t nihilism. It’s the opposite. Polite memos and cable-news panels cannot reform a party that will not keep its word. It must lose badly enough that the old incentives collapse.
The neoconservatives, the donor class and the career apologists who treated “America First” as a marketing slogan rather than a governing principle needed to feel the cost of betrayal. A controlled burn is not destruction for its own sake. It is clearing space for what comes next.
And what comes next must be planned, not improvised. Looking toward 2028, conservatives must realize that nostalgia will not rebuild the Republican Party. Neither will recycling the same establishment politicians, donor networks or “trust us this time” rhetoric. The only winning path left is a real “America First agenda,” and I mean real: no new foreign wars, an enforced border and an economy ordinary workers can afford to live in. Not selective deportations for favored industries. Not endless Middle East interventions sold as strength. Not surveillance partnerships sold as efficiency.
Anything short of that will surely fail. Voters already showed they will not show up for a counterfeit. “America First” in 2028 is not one option among many. It is the only philosophy that can reunite the base, punish the donor class that captured the party and offer a future worth fighting for.
The next candidate worth backing will have to mean it when it costs them money, headlines, and insider approval, not just when it fills a rally. Pray that God raises up someone who believes Christ is King and will put “America First.”
Until then, let the Republican Party burn. Something honest may grow in the ashes.





