By Sam Fetherlin · Staff Writer

Soccer fans have long debated the merit of a penalty shootout deciding a tied game. Critics argue it is unfair to assign a win and a loss to two teams that have just drawn. It feels like a lottery, where one team undeservedly loses despite surviving an entire game.
The truth is, a penalty shootout wasn’t ever meant to be about deserving. It’s about the separation, which parity necessitates, of two equally worthy teams, however disappointing the outcome might be for the losing side.
The Grove City men’s soccer team experienced this firsthand when Allegheny defeated Grove City on penalty kicks in the Presidents’ Athletic Conference (PAC) championship game Saturday at Don Lyle Field. After a tight 1-1 tie in regulation, two tense overtime periods followed before the decisive shootout. Allegheny emerged victorious with a 4-1 advantage on penalty kicks.
This contest was the first PAC championship game to end in a shootout since 2015. Despite the defeat, the Wolverines matched Allegheny throughout the 110-minute contest, providing an entertaining spectacle for the home fans at Don Lyle Field.
Grove City (12-2-6) entered the game confident following a dominant 6-0 semifinal victory Wednesday over Franciscan. On the other hand, Allegheny (12-6-2) came off a tough 3-2 overtime win over Geneva in its semifinal.
Any pre-match optimism was tempered somewhat by that Grove City’s only previous loss this season came at home to Allegheny three weeks earlier.
The game kicked off in cold, misty weather. The first half was a rapid, back-and-forth affair which produced 17 shots. The Wolverines led in shots 11-6 and made that superiority count with a goal at 25:40.
Senior defender Theo Campbell delivered a corner kick that senior forward Ryan Merrick headed back across goal and into the net. Campbell’s assist was his eighth of the season, tying him for third among PAC players for season assists.
Sophomore forward Andrew Perry saw a shot saved from a tight angle before heading narrowly over from close range minutes later. Allegheny gained some momentum toward the end of the half, but the Wolverines kept the halftime score 1-0.
The second period was even and intense. Three yellow cards were issued as the game grew choppier; only 11 shots were attempted in the second half. Allegheny held a 7-4 edge in second-half shots and made the most of their advantage.
At 65:27, following a free kick, Allegheny junior Ben Keefer pounced on a loose ball in the box and leveled the score at 1-1.
Few chances arrived after that, and the game went into overtime, which consisted of two 10-minute periods. The golden goal format meant that any goal would immediately end the game and crown a champion.
The 20 minutes passed by uneventfully, as each team nullified the other. The final shot count was 17-15 in favor of Grove City; the teams were level on saves, with three apiece; and the foul count was 11-12. Only a penalty shootout could decide such an even match.
It was not to be for Grove City and its eight seniors. After both teams converted their first attempts, Grove City’s second penalty was saved and its third struck the crossbar. Allegheny scored its fourth spot kick to secure its first PAC title since 1978.
This meant Allegheny qualified for the NCAA Division III tournament in December, while Grove City missed out on back-to-back tournament appearances.
The Wolverines can nevertheless take pride in a season that saw them claim top spot in the PAC regular season. That they took the championship game to a penalty shootout, that ever cruel, may be scant consolation, but it could just as easily have been Grove City lifting the PAC trophy on Saturday, and that is an achievement in and of itself.





